Wednesday, April 13, 2016

Dimensions of Understanding

1. Literal -->
2. Associative <->
3. Metaphoric <- # ->

Tuesday, April 12, 2016

Analogy

Analogy

from http://www.philosophypages.com/lg/e13.htm

Today we begin the final component of our study of logic, a survey of the most common methods of inductive reasoning. Although inductive inferences never guarantee the truth of their conclusions, as valid deductive inferences do, we can evaluate them by considering how each could be made stronger or weaker by the addition of further information.

Analogical Reasoning

The simplest variety of inductive reasoning is argument by analogy, which takes note of the fact that two or more things are similar in some respects and concludes that they are probably also similar in some further respect. Not every analogy is an argument; we frequently use such comparisons simply to explain or illustrate what we mean. But arguments by analogy are common, too.
Suppose, for example, that I am thinking about buying a new car. I'm very likely to speak with other people who have recently bought new cars, noting their experiences with various makes, models, and dealers. If I discover that three of my friends have recently bought Geo Prizms from Burg and that all three have been delighted with their purchases, then I will conclude by analogy that if I buy a Geo Prizm from Burg, I will be delighted, too.

Evaluating Analogies

Of course, this argument is not deductively valid; it is always possible that my new car may turn out to be an exception. But there are several considerations that clearly matter in determining the relative strength or weakness of my inductive inference:
  1. Number of instances. If five friends instead of three report their satisfaction with the model I intend to buy, that tends to make it even more likely that I will be satisfied, too. In general, more instances strengthen an analogy; fewer weaken it.
  2. Instance variety. If my three friends bought their Prizms from three different dealers but were all delighted, then my conclusion is somewhat more likely to be true, no matter where I decide to buy mine. In general, the more variety there is among the instances, the stronger the analogical argument becomes.
  3. Number of similarities. If my new purchase is not only the same make and model from the same dealer but also has the same engine, then my conclusion is more likely to be true. In general, the more similarities there are between the instances and my conclusion, the better for the analogical argument.
  4. Relevance. Of course, the criteria we're considering apply only if the matters with which they are concerned are relevant to the argument. Ordinarily, for example, we would assume that the day of the week on which a car was purchased is irrelevant to a buyer's satisfaction with it. But relevance is not something about which we can be terribly precise; it is always possible in principle to tell a story in the context of which anything may turn out to be relevant. So we just have to use our best judgment in deciding whether or not some respect deserves to be considered.
  5. Number of dissimilarities. If my friends all bought Geos with automatic transmissions and I plan to buy a Geo with a standard transmission, then the conclusion that I will be delighted with my purchase is a little less likely to be true. In general, the fewer dissimilarities between instances and conclusion, the better an analogical argument is.
  6. Modesty of conclusion. If all three of my friends were delighted with their auto purchases but I conclude only that I will be satisfied with mine, then this relatively modest conclusion is more likely to be true. In general, arguments by analogy are improved when their conclusions are modest with respect to their premises.

Monday, April 11, 2016

Inductive Reasoning Examples

Some examples of inductive reasoning include:
  • Jennifer leaves for school at 7:00 a.m. Jennifer is always on time. Jennifer assumes, then, that she will always be on time if she leaves at 7:00 a.m.
  • The cost of goods was $1.00. The cost of labor to manufacture the time was $.50. The sales price of the item was $5.00; so, the item always provides a good profit.
  • Every windstorm in this area comes from the north. I can see a big cloud of dust caused by a windstorm in the distance; so, a new windstorm is coming from the north.
  • Bob is showing a big diamond ring to his friend Larry. Bob has told Larry that he is going to marry Joan. Bob has bought the diamond ring to give to Joan.
  • The chair in the living room is red. The chair in the dining room is red. The chair in the bedrrom is red. All chairs in the house are red.
  • Every time you eat peanuts, your throat sweels up and you can't breath. So, you are allergic to peanuts.
  • All cats that you have observed purr. Therefore, every cat must purr.
  • Two-thirds of the students at this college receive student aid. Therefore, two-thirds of all college students receive student aid.
  • All of the girls in the class were blond, therefore all girls in this neighborhood are blond.
  • Michael just moved here from Chicago. Michael has red hair, therefore people from Chicago have red hair.
  • The children in that house yell loudly when they play in their bedroom. I can hear children yelling in that house, therefore the children must nbe playing in their bedroom.
  • All chickens that we have seen have been brown; so, all chickens are brown.
  • All cars in this town drive on the right side of the street. Therefore, all cars in all towns drive on the right side of the street.
  • John is an excellent swimmer. John's family has a swimming pool. John's sister Mary must also be an excellent swimmer.
  • All basketball players in your school are tall, so all basketball players must be tall.
  • All brown dogs in the park are small dogs. Therefore, all small dogs are brown.
  • All children in the day care center like to play with Legos. All children, therefore, enjoy playing with Legos.
  • Ray is a football player. All football players weigh more than 170 pounds. Ray weighs more than 170 pounds.
  • All observed houses on the South Street are falling apart. Sherry lives on South Street. Her house is falling apart.

Read more at http://examples.yourdictionary.com/examples-of-inductive-reasoning.html#zaSFZpsIPxZCsJ4E.99

Monday, March 21, 2016

TFY C7 IM ed

CHAPTER 7: VIEWPOINTS NOTES OVERVIEW

Important to know
 (1) the difference between liberals and conservatives, greens and libertarians; 
(2) that viewpoints could be characterized;
(3) that reality is interpreted or filtered through viewpoints; 
(4) that recognizing viewpoints engenders a detached perspective; 
(5) that critical readers always read with the context of source in mind; and 
(6) that different political points of view can be recognized through characteristic ideas and rhetoric. 

Need to reflect new shifts in social and political viewpoints, in their publications, beliefs, and rhetoric.

Need to clarify their understanding of viewpoint as well as to think more fluidly of examples through the construction of mind maps.


 “Rankings of Some Print Publications according to Reputations for Reliability.” 

 “Viewpoints in Literature” --  different viewpoints tell different stories. 

Whistleblower films.



POLITICAL VIEWPOINTS

 American magazines make considerable use of their knowledge of their consumers’ demographic profiles. Editors use this information both to shape the design and content of their publications as well as to attract appropriate advertisers. Thus publications can sometimes know more about their readers, socio-economic status, political views, and tastes than the readers might know about themselves. In studying these magazines, some students will have more difficulties than others in picking up the cues that suggest socio-economic class and political affiliations. On the other hand, many will know a lot about consumer products and consumer tastes. They might also be convinced that the ownership of certain products results in higher socio-economic status and esteem. 

Viewpoints in words as liberal and conservative
See  chart that compares conservative and liberal values. Not all will agree with my characterizations. 

Analyze arguments within the framework of viewpoints, 
Evaluate voter information pamphlets and political television commercials in order to arrive at your own decisions.

NEWS FRAMING  

Newspapers can be used in many ways: to teach observing, to teach detachment, to provide current examples of what we are studying, and to point out current topics of controversy in preparation for the final research paper. This exercise in news framing awareness challenges mastery of the skills of observing, of word awareness, and of separating facts from inferences, as well as from assumptions, evaluations, and opinions.

PROPAGANDA AND VESTED INTERESTS This section is newly written for this edition, framed as hidden viewpoints with hidden motives. The writing/discussion/research questions raise some serious issues that may require student research.

THE POWER OF IMAGE AS A PERSUADER This topic of image as a persuader is a major one deserving far more treatment since most advertisements depend upon visual persuasion. Your students might want to take this topic and run with it, bringing in their own examples to help one another recognize these persuasive techniques and their messages rather than to absorb them as givens. They could, for instance, put together a collection of photo ops of political figures and ask such questions as the following. How do they evoke positive impressions through dress, demeanor, and gestures? How do they convey trustworthiness, stability, power, and authority? How do they convey the archetype of the good father or the good mother? 


SHAPING WRITING TO THE READER’S VIEWPOINT: THE WRITER’S CHALLENGE 

Although this text does not teach audience analysis or how to anticipate reader viewpoint, this is a logical place to fit in a discussion of this subject. Students might be asked how they feel when they are writing an essay that will only be read by their instructor and how that might feel different from writing for their peers. They might also enjoy a discussion on how they might shape content differently when writing for different reading audiences. I have found it fun to interest students with this topic by playing the following as a kind of game. I write a thesis on the board—“Give me a thesis, any thesis,” I say to the class. I also write down the names of about three magazines with divergent perspectives, ranging from Reader’s Digest to Time or Salon. Then I ask the class to write down how they might want to revise this same thesis idea in order to better relate to each perspective. Sometimes we follow a revision choice with an outline of three topic sentences. This exercise encourages thinking flexibility and conveys the range of the problem without the need to have students write out a full essay or several versions of the same.

Tuesday, February 2, 2016

Word Precision Video Link

Amir Amiri's presentation for Language and Word Precision with a  reference link for session 3 on language and meaning and culture:

 As the Scholar Dr. Umar F. Abd-Allah defines language and thought during a lecture in 2014 https://youtu.be/iDBq2X-d9o0?t=2340, (part selected).

He talks about how one’s virtue is connected to their language. He uses an anecdote about people a he knows in West Africa which has a language that does not have words for cursing and talking about other people’s families aka backbiting (gossip).
“Language has a lot to do with the way we think (Aql-intellect),” “If you want to give people freedom and Justice, teach them Language.”
Language is essential to thought, clear thinking, observations, critical thinking and intellect.

Tuesday, January 19, 2016

Vaughn The Power of Critical Thinking 5e Table of Contents

Table of Contents

Preface
PART 1. BASICS
1. The Power of Critical Thinking
Why It Matters
How It Works
Claims and Reasons
Reasons and Arguments
Arguments in the Rough
Key Words
Summary
Exercises
Field Problems
Self-Assessment Quiz
Writing Assignments

2. Obstacles to Critical Thinking
Psychological Obstacles
The Almighty Self
The Power of the Group
Philosophical Obstacles
Subjective Relativism
Social Relativism
Skepticism
Key Words
Summary
Exercises
Field Problems
Self-Assessment Quiz
Integrative Exercises
Writing Assignments

3. Making Sense of Arguments
Argument Basics
Judging Arguments
Finding Missing Parts
Argument Patterns
Diagramming Arguments
Assessing Long Arguments
Key Words
Summary
Field Problems
Self-Assessment Quiz
Integrative Exercises
Writing Assignments

PART 2. REASONS
4. Reasons for Belief and Doubt
When Claims Conflict
Experts and Evidence
Personal Experience
Impairment
Expectation
Innumeracy and Probability
Fooling Ourselves
Resisting Contrary Evidence
Looking for Confirming Evidence
Preferring Available Evidence
Claims in the News
Inside the News
Sorting Out the News
Advertising and Persuasion
Identification
Slogans
Misleading Comparisons
Weasel Words
Key Words
Summary
Exercises
Field Problems
Self-Assessment Quiz
Integrative Exercises
Writing Assignments

5. Fallacies and Persuaders
Fallacies: Irrelevant Premises
Genetic Fallacy
Composition
Division
Appeal to the Person
Equivocation
Appeal to Popularity
Appeal to Tradition
Appeal to Ignorance
Appeal to Emotion
Red Herring
Straw Man
Two Wrongs Make a Right
Fallacies: Unacceptable Premises
Begging the Question
False Dilemma
Decision-Point Fallacy
Slippery Slope
Hasty Generalization
Faulty Analogy
Persuaders: Rhetorical Moves
Innuendo
Euphemisms and Dysphemisms
Stereotyping
Ridicule
Rhetorical Definitions
Key Words
Summary
Exercises
Field Problems
Self-Assessment Quiz
Integrative Exercises
Writing Assignments

PART 3. ARGUMENTS
6. Deductive Reasoning: Propositional Logic
Connectives and Truth Values
Conjunction
Disjunction
Negation
Conditional
Checking for Validity
Simple Arguments
Tricky Arguments
Streamlined Evaluation
Proof of Validity
Rules of Inference
Rules of Replacement
Proof of Validity
Key Words
Summary
Field Problems
Self-Assessment Quiz
Integrative Exercises
Writing Assignments

7. Deductive Reasoning: Categorical Logic
Statements and Classes
Translations and Standard Form
Terms
Quantifiers
Diagramming Categorical Statements
Sizing Up Categorical Syllogisms
The Square of Opposition
Categorical Equivalence
Key Words
Summary
Field Problems
Self-Assessment Quiz
Integrative Exercises
Writing Assignments

8. Inductive Reasoning
Enumerative Induction
Sample Size
Representativeness
Opinion Polls
Analogical Induction
Causal Arguments
Testing for Causes
Causal Confusions
Necessary and Sufficient Conditions
Key Words
Summary
Field Problems
Self-Assessment Quiz
Integrative Exercises
Writing Assignments

PART 4. EXPLANATIONS
9. Inference to the Best Explanation
Explanations and Inference
Theories and Consistency
Theories and Criteria
Testability
Fruitfulness
Scope
Simplicity
Conservatism
Telling Good Theories from Bad
A Doomed Flight
An Amazing Cure
Key Words
Summary
Field Problems
Self-Assessment Quiz
Integrative Exercises
Writing Assignments

10. Judging Scientific Theories
Science and Not Science
The Scientific Method
Testing Scientific Theories
Judging Scientific Theories
Copernicus Versus Ptolemy
Evolution Versus Creationism
Science and Weird Theories
Making Weird Mistakes
Leaping to the Weirdest Theory
Mixing What Seems with What Is
Misunderstanding the Possibilities
Judging Weird Theories
Crop Circles
Talking with the Dead
Summary
Field Problems
Self-Assessment Quiz
Integrative Exercises
Writing Assignments

11. Critical Thinking in Morality and the Law
Moral Arguments
Moral Premises
Moral Theories
Evaluating Moral Theories
Two Important Theories
Legal Reasoning
A Coherent Worldview
Key Words
Summary
Exercises
Field Problems
Self-Assessment Quiz
Integrative Exercises
Writing Assignments
Appendix A: Essays for Evaluation
1. "Death Penalty Discriminates Against Black Crime Victims,"USA Today
2. "Marine Parks," Bill Daly
3. "A Feminist Defense of Pornography," Wendy McElroy
4. "A Defense of Homosexuality," John Corvino
5. "More Innocents Die When We Don't Have Capital Punishment," Dennis Prager
6. "What's Wrong with Adultery?" Bonnie Steinbock
7. "A Pat-Down Is Better than a Blow-Up," Caroline Baum
8. "The Cohabitation Epidemic," Neil Clark Warren
9. "Not Being Vaccinated Is Not Acceptable,"David Ropeik
10. "Women and the Afghanistan Peace Process," Ann Jones
11. "A Deviance from God's Norm," Richard Land
12. "Marriage Still Evolving, as Ever," Buffalo News
13. "Slouching Toward Chimeras," Jeremy Rifkin
14. "Fighting Islamic Extremists Who Stifle Free Speech," Ayaan Hirsi and Daniel Huff
15. "Is Sluttishness a Feminist Statement?" Wendy Kaminer
16. "Torture: Time for Congress to End the Debate," USA Today
17. "Torture: Severe Interrogations Work," Trent Franks
18. "Freedom of Expression: Protect Student Speech—Even 'Unwise' Bong Banner," USA Today
19. "Freedom of Expression: Policy Reflects Common Sense,"Kenneth W. Starr
20. "It's Irresponsible to Spread Fear of Vaccine," USA Today
21. "Flag Amendment: Flag Needs Protection," Dianne Feinstein
Appendix B. Answers to Exercises
Appendix C. Answers to Self-Assessment Quizzes
Appendix D. Critical Thinking and Writing
Notes
Glossary
Credits
Index

Tuesday, December 1, 2015

Deductive and Inductive Arguments

Deductive and Inductive Arguments


A deductive argument is an argument that is intended by the arguer to be (deductively) valid, that is, to provide a guarantee of the truth of the conclusion provided that the argument's premises (assumptions) are true. This point can be expressed also by saying that, in a deductive argument, the premises are intended to provide such strong support for the conclusion that, if the premises are true, then it would be impossible for the conclusion to be false. An argument in which the premises do succeed in guaranteeing the conclusion is called a (deductively) valid argument. If a valid argument has true premises, then the argument is said to be sound.
Here is a valid deductive argument: It's sunny in Singapore. If it's sunny in Singapore, he won't be carrying an umbrella. So, he won't be carrying an umbrella.
Here is a mildly strong inductive argument: Every time I've walked by that dog, he hasn't tried to bite me. So, the next time I walk by that dog he won't try to bite me.
An inductive argument is an argument that is intended by the arguer merely to establish or increase the probability of its conclusion. In an inductive argument, the premises are intended only to be so strong that, if they were true, then it would be unlikely that the conclusion is false. There is no standard term for a successful inductive argument. But its success or strength is a matter of degree, unlike with deductive arguments. A deductive argument is valid or else invalid.
The difference between the two kinds of arguments does not lie solely in the words used; it comes from the relationship the author or expositor of the argument takes there to be between the premises and the conclusion. If the author of the argument believes that the truth of the premises definitely establishes the truth of the conclusion (due to definition, logical entailment, logical structure, or mathematical necessity), then the argument is deductive. If the author of the argument does not think that the truth of the premises definitely establishes the truth of the conclusion, but nonetheless believes that their truth provides good reason to believe the conclusion true, then the argument is inductive.
Some analysts prefer to distinguish inductive arguments from conductive arguments; the latter are arguments giving explicit reasons for and against a conclusion, and requiring the evaluator of the argument to weigh these considerations, i.e., to consider the pros and cons. This article considers conductive arguments to be a kind of inductive argument.
The noun "deduction" refers to the process of advancing or establishing a deductive argument, or going through a process of reasoning that can be reconstructed as a deductive argument. "Induction" refers to the process of advancing an inductive argument, or making use of reasoning that can be reconstructed as an inductive argument.
Because deductive arguments are those in which the truth of the conclusion is thought to be completely guaranteed and not just made probable by the truth of the premises, if the argument is a sound one, then the truth of the conclusion is said to be "contained within" the truth of the premises; that is, the conclusion does not go beyond what the truth of the premises implicitly requires. For this reason, deductive arguments are usually limited to inferences that follow from definitions, mathematics and rules of formal logic. Here is a deductive argument:
John is ill. If John is ill, then he won't be able to attend our meeting today. Therefore, John won't be able to attend our meeting today.
That argument is valid due to its logical structure. If 'ill' were replaced with 'happy', the argument would still be valid because it would retain its special logical structure (called modus ponens). Here is the form of any argument having the structure of modus ponens:
P
If P then Q
So, Q
The capital letters stand for declarative sentences, or statements, or propositions. The investigation of these logical forms is called Propositional Logic.
The question of whether all, or merely most, valid deductive arguments are valid because of their structure is still controversial in the field of the philosophy of logic, but that question will not be explored further in this article.
Inductive arguments can take very wide ranging forms. Inductive arguments might conclude with some claim about a group based only on information from a sample of that group. Other inductive arguments draw conclusions by appeal to evidence or authority or causal relationships. Here is a somewhat strong inductive argument based on authority:
The police said John committed the murder. So, John committed the murder.
Here is an inductive argument based on evidence:
The witness said John committed the murder. So, John committed the murder.
Here is a stronger inductive argument based on better evidence:
Two independent witnesses claimed John committed the murder. John's fingerprints are the only ones on the murder weapon. John confessed to the crime. So, John committed the murder.
This last argument is no doubt good enough for a jury to convict John, but none of these three arguments about John committing the murder is strong enough to be called valid. At least itt is not valid in the technical sense of 'deductively valid'. However, some lawyers will tell their juries that these are valid arguments, so we critical thinkers need to be on the alert as to how people around us are using the term.
It is worth noting that some dictionaries and texts improperly define "deduction" as reasoning from the general to specific and define "induction" as reasoning from the specific to the general. These definitions are outdated and inaccurate. For example, according to the more modern definitions given above, the following argument from the specific to general is deductive, not inductive, because the truth of the premises guarantees the truth of the conclusion:
The members of the Williams family are Susan, Nathan and Alexander.
Susan wears glasses.
Nathan wears glasses.
Alexander wears glasses.
Therefore, all members of the Williams family wear glasses.
Moreover, the following argument, even though it reasons from the general to specific, is inductive:
It has snowed in Massachusetts every December in recorded history.
Therefore, it will snow in Massachusetts this coming December.
It is worth noting that the proof technique used in mathematics called "mathematical induction", is deductive and not inductive. Proofs that make use of mathematical induction typically take the following form:
Property P is true of the number 0.
For all natural numbers n, if P holds of n then P also holds of n + 1.
Therefore, P is true of all natural numbers.
When such a proof is given by a mathematician, it is thought that if the premises are true, then the conclusion follows necessarily. Therefore, such an argument is deductive by contemporary standards.
Because the difference between inductive and deductive arguments involves the strength of evidence which the author believes the premises to provide for the conclusion, inductive and deductive arguments differ with regard to the standards of evaluation that are applicable to them. The difference does not have to do with the content or subject matter of the argument. Indeed, the same utterance may be used to present either a deductive or an inductive argument, depening on the intentions of the person advancing it. Consider as an example.
Dom Perignon is a champagne, so it must be made in France.
It might be clear from context that the speaker believes that having been made in the Champagne area of France is part of the defining feature of "champagne" and so the conclusion follows from the premise by definition. If it is the intention of the speaker that the evidence is of this sort, then the argument is deductive. However, it may be that no such thought is in the speaker's mind. He or she may merely believe that nearly all champagne is made in France, and may be reasoning probabilistically. If this is his or her intention, then the argument is inductive.
It is also worth noting that, at its core, the distinction between deductive and inductive  has to do with the strength of the justification that the author or expositor of the argument intends that the premises provide for the conclusion. If the argument is logically fallacious, it may be that the premises actually do not provide justification of that strength, or even any justification at all. Consider, the following argument:
All odd numbers are integers.
All even numbers are integers.
Therefore, all odd numbers are even numbers.
This argument is logically fallacious because it is invalid. In actuality, the premises provide no support whatever for the conclusion. However, if this argument were ever seriously advanced, we must assume that the author would believe that the truth of the premises guarantees the truth of the conclusion. Therefore, this argument is still deductive. A bad deductive argument is not an inductive argument.